Course review
Michel Thomas language courses: a review
7 min readLast updated: October 2026
Michel Thomas was one of the world's most famous language teachers when he died in 2005.
And for his private sessions he was one of the most expensive, with his website advertising his week long sessions (well five days actually) at prices reported to run into the thousands of dollars. He built a long list of well heeled celebrity clients and eventually released versions of his courses on audio CD. His star-studded cast included Princess Grace of Monaco! Wow!
Update: today the Michel Thomas Method courses are published by Hodder & Stoughton, in up to 19 languages, and sold online to stream or download through the Michel Thomas Method app.
The Michel Thomas audio courses are available in numerous languages and give one some good practical methods to grab the basics of a language and to build confidence in speaking a new foreign language.
Overall however with their emphasis on being purely audio they are very much one dimensional and while useful for some aspects of language learning, they need to be supplemented with other forms of language tuition. No complex multimedia stuff, but great for learning a language in the car, or on your phone.
I listened to the Michel Thomas French CD Audio Course 1, and rated it as worth having as a part of your language learning stable of tools and can say that it had some very good points.
However I should firstly issue a....
Word of Caution about the Michel Thomas French Audio CD Language Course
Listen to some native speakers
For the Michel Thomas French audio course I do also add a word of caution.
Despite Michel studying at the Sorbonne University in Paris, and his ability to speak French, his accent is not a native French accent. And for any French student to adopt as good an accent as possible, one needs to listen to native speakers. One can also watch French speakers (TV, films, videos, etc), and watch and mimic their mouths, facial expressions and actions when they talk.
It is therefore important to add a component of your learning which includes extensive tracts from native speakers.
Michel Thomas was born in Poland in 1914, grew up in Germany, and moved to France at nineteen to study. All of this comes through in his accent.
Michel Thomas speaks French with a noticeable foreign accent (Polish and German, to my ear). Like his strong personality it comes through strongly in his French, and in his English. It is not the accent you want to copy.
If a friend of yours was learning English, you would want them practising their pronunciation with a native speaker, and most courses out there use one.
OK, so how do you get around this?
On the course I listened to there was no native speaker to back him up, or to put the students on the right track.
I cannot comment on the accent on the Michel Thomas Spanish course, Michel Thomas Italian, Michel Thomas Portuguese, Michel Thomas German course or the Michel Thomas anything else. [See Addendum below - ed]
I would be interested in any feedback!
But if you are considering one of these courses I would strongly recommend that you get a native speaker to have a listen to somebody else's copy of the course to give him a rating on his accent.
Use his teachings for practical conversation and learning some structure, and some handy hints about conversing in the language, but get a native speaker to teach you how to pronounce words. Do not use his French course as your only learning material.
Addendum: Michel Thomas German course
I got some native German speakers to listen to Michel Thomas's German course and they rate him as a native German speaker. You can therefore use his German lessons in the full confidence of knowing that he has a native German accent.
Michel Thomas Language Learning Techniques
The Thomas technique concentrates heavily on cognates, that is using words that are similar in French and in English. This is great for giving students a level of confidence, and some useful tricks.
He covers the modal verbs heavily, these being very useful for practical everyday situations. These are the verbs like would, should, could, can etc. Good stuff.
Are the Michel Thomas Language courses good for the serious student?
For the serious student of modern foreign languages however you will need much more than a Michel Thomas language audio CD course to learn a language and become fluent. His publishers now offer follow-on courses (see the update at the end).
The audio CD courses are great for the basics, but the student that is genuinely interested in becoming fluent needs around 600 to 900 hours of class time to learn a language like French, Spanish or German, according to the experts like the Foreign Service Institute who train the US diplomats in language learning.
From my look at Mr Thomas's French language course 1, his audio courses simply do not provide this level of teaching. (But you have to decide on what level you are aiming at!). Nevertheless his courses are a great starting point.
Be careful of purely audio courses
Being a purely audio method of teaching means that one does not get to see any written text. This is a serious drawback because a person that can read language learning material can learn much more effectively. Reading words and text increases and solidifies the language learning experience immensely and allows the reader to more accurately identify and learn a word or phrase.
Something heard is often not quite clear to the listener, whereas if one can listen and read then one has a better learning experience.
If we look at the brain's method of learning we know that the more stimulus and input from the more different senses that we use, the greater are the number of neural pathways that are laid in the brain as each brain cell, neuron connects to loads of other neurons.
So by adding reading, writing, video, animation, acting and other things one is incorporating all the senses that audio courses like Mr Thomas's language courses neglect, you will improve the quality and depth of your learning experience.
Overall the Michel Thomas language courses do have a place in your language learning stable of products, but I do not recommend them as the sole learning methodology. Include a good, qualified language teacher, books, TV, films, DVD, verb drills etc.
And for the best foreign language vocabulary learning and gender recognition techniques use the 200 Words a Day language learning systems. These are the perfect complement to any language learning course for Spanish, French, German and Italian (Welsh coming soon).
Learning a Language with No Memorization? ... as Mr Thomas claims
Mr Thomas claims that his techniques require no memorization, and he makes quite a point of this. Well you can call the process what you like, but you still have to memorize things in some way to get them into your brain.
You can call an elephant a donkey if you want, but it is still an elephant. You can call it an aeroplane (... a jumbo maybe...) or can call it a gillywolkawilbydidliackadoondom, but it is also still an elephant.
My point is that you do have to try and remember things. This process is called memorization! Just because the teacher says it requires no memorization does not mean it is so. If you don't remember something you will never learn it! If you have not memorized something it is not in your brain!
But this is of course a great sales pitch from one of the greatest ever sellers of language courses! No memorization!
Overall - a good thing to have in the language learning stable... Just go in with your eyes open.
Update, October 2026
Michel Thomas died in 2005. His courses are now published by Hodder & Stoughton in 19 languages and sold through the Michel Thomas app (there is a free trial), with Foundation, Advanced and vocabulary courses for the main languages, rather than on CD. For French, Spanish, German and Italian the recordings are still his own voice, so everything above about pairing them with native-speaker audio still applies; most of the other languages are taught by native speakers.
Readers' comments on Michel Thomas
Posted between 2008 and 2012, and shown with first names only.
I read your review of Michel Thomas's French. The thick accent is indeed a pitfall, although the Russian, Arabic, and Mandarin courses all use native speakers.
I pretty much agree with everything you've written about Michel Thomas, but I think you failed to mention the strongest area of the program; and for this I will take an excerpt from a language learning forum:
The central underlying secret to Michel Thomas's technique existed in two parts -
1. Firstly, a system for breaking down language into its core essence, and then ...
2. secondly putting it together in a way the students could understand.
Susan reckons his Italian accent is pretty close ...
Regarding your comments on Michel Thomas' language learning techniques and accents. I have undertaken the Italian courses and have found Michel's accent to be very close to native Italian - and I can say that with confidence as my father is Italian and I practised what I learnt with him.
The course is aimed at people who want to SPEAK as opposed to read. That is why it does not use diagrams etc. But all the courses have accompanying booklets containing the course contents i.e. the dialogue. So if someone really wants to see how what they are saying is written, it is provided for them.
If you read who they say each course is intended for you will see that they never state it is a substitute for serious academic study. I cannot comment about any other of the languages on offer, but I am much more confident with my Italian and and am now at Year 4 GCSE level having been 'bumped up' from year 1 after doing the Michel Thomas method - and my Italian teacher is a native speaker also.
That is great to hear. I wonder how he could manage an Italian accent, but not lose the Polish brogue with his English and his French. Amazing given his 'world's greatest language teacher' label.
— Kevin, in reply
More on Michel Thomas's Italian accent...
The reason is simple. Italian phonology is relatively easier than English or French phonology. It is a phonetic language.
I don't speak Italian, and my native language is very distant from European languages, but when I try to read Italian (without understanding of course) native speakers say that I sound like an immigrant who has lived in Italy for more than 40 years. On the other hand, my father is an English language professor, specializing in Phonetics and Phonology, and yet his accent is far from native.
English is very difficult phonetically and phonologically!
Why did Michel Thomas neglect the woman student on his Total French course?
Before I criticise Michel Thomas, I would like to emphasise how much I learned from his latest "Total French" course for beginners.
Thomas had an amazing system for making complexities simple, eg. how to avoid getting le/la, un/une wrong in spoken French, how to use contractions to help with the phrasing of spoken French, and how to quickly construct and use (his) "auxiliary verbs" as "handles" to avoid conjugating verbs you don't know how to conjugate.
I also gained a lot of confidence to speak out loud in French. And I would recommend them as a great starting point.
That said, I spent most of CDs 5, 6 & 7 distressed and wondering what happened to the woman student he was teaching. He hardly gave her a chance to reply to any of his "How would you say..." questions from CD5 onwards. Yet Thomas told her, in the very first lesson, that she did not have to memorise each new sentence, that it was his job to teach her; all she had to do was "relax, take it slowly, and think it through".
But he abandonned her on CD5.
She tried to ask a question about half way through, but he talked over her and did not give her another chance to speak for several lessons.
It was obvious by the end of CD#7 (the last one) that she hadn't, in fact, learnt anything much since CD#4.
It's just not true that his (Socratic?) method means you don't have to memorise if you want to finish the course successfully.
In regard to the written word and native accents:
The new Michel Thomas "Total French" course for beginners does come with a booklet of every sentence and phrase spoken on all 7 CDs, as well as Thomas' key rules and tips.
There are two additional Vocabulary CDs which use the same method as Thomas and the teacher/facilitator is a (non-native) female who is very easy to understand.
However, she is "teaching" two adult, native French speakers, whom she talks to patronisingly as if they are learning French ("Well done!" she says at one point). And she praises Thomas and his Method constantly, even using some of her praises as phrases to be translated by the "students". These two Vocab CDs were quite sickening for me to listen to ... and they didn't introduce many practical every-day words. It was mostly focused on what Thomas had already told us - about how to work the French word from the English word.
But all in all, I'd recommend it as a good start for beginners who have, at least, a little basic knowledge of French already.
The comments about the female student are hilarious, and I agree with a lot of them. That American woman was thick as a leaf. I do wonder if she ever actually learned French, or if she gave up entirely after recording those CDs. To be fair, her complete lack of wit sometimes made me feel better; if I got something wrong, she’d almost always get it wrong too.
— Soe Moe from Burma, in reply
Are we sure it was a woman, I was convinced it was 20 y.o. boy transitioning and trying to sport a female voice. I thought that’s why his accent was so bad and his grasp of the language was so poor..because his brain was trying so hard to sound female. It’s hard to act and learn at the same time.
— Anonymous, in reply
I also found the woman annoying. She seemed a bit slow and yet at the same time theatrical. Toward the end, she started to sound so much like Marlo Thomas from the show, That Girl, and the album, Free to be You and Me, that I had to stop and google it, which is how I came across this hilarious thread. If she was part of the master plan or the method, then wow, cool, I'd like to know more. Also je voudrais savoir about the hypnotique suggestions. Overall, I'm so glad I found this method I can deal with the annoying woman.
— Anonymous, in reply
He started ignoring because she just kept interrupting the teaching with her silly little noises and comments. I think he was very good with her until he couldn't tolerate her stupidity any longer. I simply re-recoded the series and edited her out altogether!
Before there is the slightest criticism of Michel Thomas, try coping with the woman on the "Michel Thomas Method" Greek with her constant salad/sandwich/ouzo/ system of teaching any vocabulary.
— Rexcal, in reply
I am astounded at the nasty comments about the female student!
— Anonymous, in reply
A teacher can do only but so much. I applaud Michel Thomas for tolerating her for as many CDs as he did. She treated the course like a silly superficial game because that's all she was capable of grasping. Half the time, I could tell if she was purring or gargling amid her silly and meaningless responses to his questions and explanations. I'm surprised Michel didn't oust her and suggest she contribute to a remedial pre-school CD. It was pretty obvious she never mastered conjugation of English verbs and English usage, so whoever chose her for this course must have been dead drunk or on something stronger.
— Ranger, in reply
Language learning is not an easy task for the brain. In this effort, to hear such a cheerful lady with such a sexy voice, giggling and taking it so easy filled me with joy and made me smile and laugh several times. She was like a prophet telling people 'hey, life is not that serious'. I think i fell in love with a stranger. :)
— Anonymous, in reply
She has the incredible ability to be unbelievably annoying more or les every time she opens her mouth. Very detrimental to the quality of the course, but the fault is with whoever chose her to be on the audio course in the first place.
— AndrewAnonymous, in reply
Thank goodness he abandoned that stupid woman by CD5! She was so annoying, I wanted to strangle her by the end of CD1.
I understand having a slower learner on the CD for the listener’s confidence, but that woman has got to be marginally mentally challenged. She interrupted frequently, learned nothing and her ridiculous over pronunciation would make Pepe Le Peu irritated!
If you liked the American accent and our general informal friendly nature, at least hire one with basic ability to learn.
I actually googled this to see if she annoyed anyone else. Of course the answer is "Oui".
— Ashley, in reply
If anyone ever finds out who or where this woman is please tell. I would gladly go around to her house and criticise he curtains. she is utterly obnoxious and such a sycophant.
I could have finished the course in a week had it not been for the number of times I had to stop the recording and swear loudly or throw things around the room.
— Geldrith, in reply
The way he constantly criticized her I kept expecting her to break down in tears! The only thing missing was him calling her a stupid bitch.
— Bond, Lawrence Bond, in reply
The way he constantly criticized her I kept expecting her to break down in tears! The only thing missing was him calling her a stupid bitch.
— Bond, Lawrence Bond, in reply
The woman is intolerable. I have listened to the CD's a billion times and I hate her more each time. She obviously has a moderate intellectual delay because even after a word is clearly said, she insists on changing it every single time. There was also her ridiculous over pronunciation of any new French word she heard. I can't believe Michel didn't strangle her. I would have.
She also did this annoying thing where she tried to be cute in a pathetic sniveling attempt to ingratiate herself with Mr Thomas. She makes me wanna vomit. I wanna kick her till she's xxx.
— Anonymous, in reply
She makes a lot of noise on the recording, but very little of that noise is speaking French.
— Anonymous, in reply
MT DIDN'T ignore her!! She was too thick to answer the question! She could barely do so in the first 4 CDs but by CD5 onwards , when it had notched up a little in difficulty, her utter stupidity came into its own. All she then did was utter banal sighs and whispering a repeat of the Englishman's answer.
How MT kept it together when faced with that level of moronic response was quite amazing. She isn't completely quiet as she would still interrupt the lesson to ask a question about a word that Michel had only told her 5 seconds previously.Thank God they used intelligent people for the Advanced course
— Northbanker, in reply
I am using the Michel Thomas Foundation course and just out of interest searched for why he almost completely ignored the female studet for the last considerable time. Practically every single question he puts to the man! Not the best teaching practice!
— Andrew, in reply
BUMLOUDSON IS RIGHT. Nobody can learn a language that quickly .I do not care how clever you are.I speak 6 languages and it took YEARS of hard work.
— Lars Arenhole, in reply
I listened to the entire MTF audios, and I have to admit that the lady (as fun as she was) slowed me down in the learning process.
MT was only thinking about the people that had to listen to her blatant annoying mistakes. If I was the teacher I would neglect her no problem.
I would recommend this to anyone as it is a great way to learn french (and different languages). Thanks to this method and a good book I speak French fluently "apparently".
Happy new year all and happy language learning x
— Nova, in reply
Don't listen to Bumbledum's CANNOT! He eithet hasn't experienced Michel Thomas' teaching for more than a few minutes or he is extremely slow learner.
MTM promises to teach you the necessary grammar and pronunciation in 12 hours and that's exactly what it did for me. The vocab can be learnt as you travel in the country and speak to natives.
I am now doing the MTM Greek and Greek Advanced courses which are also fabulous but not quite as effective because Michel is not the teacher. Michel uses additional techniques that are perhaps not obvious to people not trained in hypnosis or auto-suggestion techniques.
I will pick up the vocab as I travel but I already now how to structure sentences in Greek and pronounce any Greek text.
— Anonymous, in reply
I think the male student had a slightly better understanding of French than the female student, though I have to admit, I loved the female students' American-English accent and her bubbly enthusiasm. I think the two students complimented each other really well.
— Anonymous, in reply
It is as simple as this-it takes YEARS to learn a new language.No matter what anybody says .. You CANNOT Learn a new language in days or weeks ,it simply is not true. As for not memorising things,well, that is utter rubbish.
I have found that if I study for an hour a day for several days and then take a break for a few days and do not think anything about the language , I tend to learn far more.
Also I have found that I learn far more if I do not bother about grammar rules and verb tables .I just listen to native speakers ,so Thomas was right about that I reckon.
— Bumloudson, in reply
It's part of the method.. you have one quick student and one slow. When the slow student is struggling you shout out the answer and it reinforces it in yourself.
— Anonymous, in reply
terrible students
The two people learning french on the cd's have absolutely no clue whatsoever. It's as though they are not even listening to the teacher. Especially the woman. A lot of the time her terrible pronounciation and mistakes put me off quite a bit and frustrated me alot!
I just found her to be irritating. Her under-the-breath attempts along with her triumphant-sounding outbursts grated on my nerves.
— Anonymous, in reply
Michel was probably aware of the problem and ditched the two students for two savvy younger ones, who seemed to soak up the language like a sponge. Although, I think they betrayed some previous learning.
I didn't see the woman in his intro course as a problem though. She was probably representative of her age cohort. I gathered she must have been middle aged. And learning a language at that age is difficult as the brain has lost a lot of its lingual plasticity.
Over all, I think Michel and his students did an excellent job.
— Anonymous, in reply
Language is hard, he makes it as simple as possible
Thanks for your review,
I feel the key thing is the level at which you wish to acheive. (as you have mentioned)
For someone wishing to take a holiday and to be able to have a basic conversation without having to learn the nit-picky ins and outs of a new language then this is a great choice.
Of course it will rely on the other person giving more effort to understand then with a native speaker and I think learning his accent is not major problem.. Have you ever spoke with a French person talking English? Many retain a very strong french accent but are still understandable.
I think it's a learning technique that suits people such as myself who's written language is terrible, dyslexia is a constant burden for me but I love to travel so this is an amazing way to be taught for the reasons I have stated. I see a lot of review knocking the teaching method but without this guy Michel Thomas, I would probably not be able to speak any Spanish or French as I find the standard teaching technique far to slow, far to in depth and far to difficult to retain.
Thanks for for letting me voice an opinion on this guy on your website, I feel he deserves some more positive feedback on the Internet.
English Accent
I struggled to understand his English accent/pronunciation on the first Spanish CD!
He was trying to say something along the lines of "words ending in -ably", but in his pronunciation of "-ably", he had added in an extra random syllable. English is my first language, and I had to listen to it twice to actually understand what he meant.
If this was his best effort at English, I'm assuming the Spanish is just as bad, so immediately gave up on his course.
teach to pass for a native?
I very much get why there is no 'beware, non native' warning. Why people, who live 40 years in immersion do not lose their accent? It is silly of you to presume that any internet, non bespoke, course can do much to nativise a learner's accent. There are situations, jobs where students should try or care to pass for a native, yet these need special accent trainers.
Else I sometimes do not like his Michel's mannerism...still there should not be an irritable teacher warning.
Michel Thomas was a genius!
Michel Thomas was a genius, and whatever his defects, he makes learning a language easy,and will put you ahead in that task,no matter what other method you may later add to it. Besides which,he makes learning language fun!
The dutch and Russian courses are taught by native speakers
I have taken both courses, all the way through basic and advanced. The teachers are native speakers and in the dutch one, there even 2 different teachers who teach you 2 different native accents.
If you supplement it with reading and writing on your own, it does help taking off!!
Incredible method
Honestly,
Michel Thomas is fantastic. Regardless of accents which will differ in any area or region, I picked up to intermediate French in a record time.
His method is unlike anything I have tried, including Rosetta, part time classes and many other methods.
If you put your mind to it, this is by far the best method to my experience.
Michel Thomas Spanish course
His Spanish course is good, but his Polish/German accent is obvious in the recording. So I would say, along with the French program, you should have a native speaker help with pronunciation in Spanish. The method itself is wonderful - and I'm a Spanish teacher!
Memorization: I think you missed the point....
Michel doesn't mention anything bad or negative about memorizing words in the content of his courses: of course memorization is a part of how we learn!!! Great point, Einstein.
What he does say is that it's important in this context not to think very hard about what you've learned, to use your thinking lightly when recalling words - its not based on an analytical approach to learning, its an approach based on insight.
If you consciously "try" to remember each and every word, you'll likely struggle and exhaust yourself, and probably damage your confidence with learning the language. By avoiding this mistake, you'll make the proccess relatively effortless and pain free.
Accent Engages The Minds of Idealists Only
I am using some of the MT series. Russian, French, Spanish, Italian are among the ones I tried. They are excellent. Accent is the least important thing for me as a polyglot. I am a native Persian Speaker. The only correct accent of mine is Persian. Even though I have a phd in English, I do not consider my English accent purely American. I simply do not want it. I want communication only and my heavy accent in some of the languages I know never hindered my communication with native speakers.
Another important thing is the human brain is very clever. Even though you learn, lets say french, with a foreign accent, when listening to an authentic audio source, your brain modifies the input and although difficult at the beginning, it will ultimately grasps the meaning.
Learn French with MT and then watch TV5 Monde, you will have no problem understanding a lot.
I am not perfectionist. Perfectionism in Language learning hinders you a lot. Finally, learn the language with any tool you can, audio, video, books and grammar books.
All the methods work only if you are damn eager to learn any language. In how many languages can you be a native accent show-offer? Get rid of these worries and just learn the languages.
Accents
Hello,
It is not the first time that I have heard/read comments about his accent. He created a method, now the MT method is applied to many languages and I guess that - as long as the target language's teacher is both a native speaker and fluent in English, everyone (maybe not everyone, there will always be one who picks holes) is happy and no-one complains about accents.
I am Italian, he might have an accent but I would recommend his Italian course one million times compared to the boring books etc from which hardly anyone seems to have ever learnt as much and as quickly as with this method.
Michel to me is the best option if you cannot travel to the country of the language you want to learn.
If he - HE - had not created this method, WE would not have this method.
I read with a smile the jokes about elephants being seen as donkeys yet they are still elephants etc: on the same lines, I feel like saying that in order to appease the people who complain about the accent of the creator of a method of language learning, Michel Thomas should have been born in 6 different countries and experienced 6 lives, being born in 6 different places, growing up in 6 different cultures and being able to speak 6 mother tongues. He would have been six people. But He was ONE, I pay tribute to this man. He/it could have not been any different.
Alex
One of the best ever
With the Michel Thomas' approach students start speaking early on because they understand how the language works and what it takes to start using it from scratch. What I like best about it is that they start speaking immediately and most courses I am familiar with take students some time to become confident and begin using it. I speak eight different languages and I can tell if I had started learning them with the Michel Thoma's method I would have learned earlier and would be able to keep on learning more foreign languages.
Start with Michel Thomas to gain confidence speaking!
Yes I probably speak with a Polish-German accent, but now I am confident to have a go at speaking out loud in class because I have more confidence with the structure and grammar than my fellow students and I know how to pronounce any word, and I know how to stress words the way the French do.
Next, I will use other methods that involve native French speakers and hopefully my accent (new that it is) will change for the better - either way, a Polish-French accent is still better than an Australian-French accent!
One Tip: The MT method works best if you give it your total concentration. I don't believe it is a method of teaching that would work well if you try to learn it while driving (as do the rapid learning techniques which involve music, eg: Berlitz Earworms CDs).
Jezza11 in Oz
Michel Thomas' courses
In factMichel Thomas' courses are excellent for anyone getting started in any foreign language, but of course, you must start reading books, magazines and newspapers early on.
Why the confusion?
I find it staggering that people seriously thought that he would be a "native" speaker in 4 languages. Surely when for example buying his French CD someone would think "oh that guy also does German,Spanish and Italian". Is there anyone who has ever lived who can truly speak 4 languages or more AS A NATIVE?
I find the courses excellent grounding for forming sentences and starting to use the language. Of course it does not mean you will reach fluency without learning copious amounts of vocabulary too but I much prefer to that myself rather than pay for silly courses such as Vocabulearn or Learn in Your Car where someone just reads out a vocabulary list to you. What on earth is the point of that?
Use Michel Thomas to learn the grammatical basics and structure of the language but supplement it with listening to natives and learning vocab.
So the things that frustrate me with MT:
1. the Titling of "Total" "Perfect" and "Masterclass". These are all complete misnomers and frankly the Total is no more than a basic course, the Perfect and Masterclass intermediate.
2. The Vocabulary courses are a bit odd and I would not recommend them unless you want to hear the name Michel Thomas 1000 times in the first 10 minutes. It is a poor attempt to pretend that the methods being used would be approved by the late MT.
3. A Test of Courage. I never realised Michel Thomas won the Second World War by himself but reading this would suggest he did.
Summary: Buy the language courses, they are fun and much more engaging that most courses but don't expect it to be a shortcut to fluency.
He teaches real conversational french not an academic exercise
Michel Thomas simplifies learning enormously. Anyone can learn the structure and vocabulary almost effortlessly due to his extraordinary methods - making lists and revision are not allowed, no forced remembering - just allowing the language to flow and being reenforced through his wonderful techniques. No other language teaching can compare. He emphasizes the correct pronunciation constantly explaining how words are run together in common speech (for example je ne sais pas becomes jn sais pas). Absolutely excellent.
To say he has the wrong accent is nonsense. He is not teaching perfect French as an academic exercise, but real conversational French with all its intonations and character.
Italian accent
I listened to many of the CDs using the Michel Thomas method for Italian. I really enjoyed the method and learnt a lot from it. I would not say that his accent is close to a native Italian accent; however his pronunciation is very good. That is, he does not make many errors at all in important Italian pronunciation points (e.g. double consonants, the vowel sounds are distinguishable, etc). However, his accent sounds like native German to me when he speaks English, Italian and French.
When Michel Thomas passed away, some other materials were made in Italian that involved an American woman teaching. I find it awful to listen to, as her American accent is incredibly strong when speaking Italian and she makes very obvious and important errors in pronunciation, often!
I've also seen other reviewers comment on this. They do use a native Italian speaker in these CDs (after the pause when the listener practises the word); however the woman is the one teaching and the main one to speak Italian.
She has the last word, so it sounds like she is correcting the pronunciation of the native speaker (e.g. "Very good: (her pronunciation)". Having said that, the method is so good I still learnt a lot from listening to those CDs!
ACCENT- NOT IMPORTANT
Thats what i discovered.in most schools teachers will tell you how to pronounce but does not have capacity of making grammar rules understandable.so even if you can pronouce a word correctly but cant make a sentence in your head after years of earning-whats the point to put emphasis on the accent.
Mishel is great.if you want to get right accent mix his courses with paul noble,or pimsleur. oor just watch movies like i do with no english subs. really helps
Michel Thomas French
I am using the Michel Thomas French course. I think that it is fantastic, and my boyfriend, a native French speaker, is greatly impressed.
Belgian accent more than French accent.
I'm a French native speaker and I listened to some French Michel Thomas courses, just to make sure of the quality of his lessons. His accent his very good, but I would say that it sounds a bit like a Belgian accent. But any one who tries to imitate exactly the Michel Thomas accent would be understood wihout any problem by French native speakers.
Brilliant method with one small catch...
Michel Thomas method should not be underestimated! It is a VERY GOOD system that will get you talking in the language effortlessly.
As someone who has learnt Spanish using it as a key aide, then gone to the country and lived there for three years, the only problem you are likely to have is that you will sound immediately like you are fluent.
Native speakers will then talk to you fluently, and you will not understand them. Not immediately. That is because although your grammar will be very good, comparable to theirs, you will not have a broad vocabulary, you will not be used to their grammatical nuances (local errors), or colloquial language. And when you add all that up, you'll find your confidence knocked somewhat, because you thought you were fluent.
Having said that, it is a brilliant foundation, and to be highly recommended. You dont need a good accent when you first go - your accent can be rubbish, it will soon improve if you go to the country, and it will ONLY improve if you are able to communicate with the locals, which is what this will give you.
Overall, it is a very good method that is to be recommended.
About Michel Thomas Polish accent and about accent in general
I am a native Polish speaker living in English speaking country for 25 years and I think I know English well.
I just read Michel Thomas biography and was surprised to find that he is a Polish Jew who was born in Poland and lived there his child and youth years.
I can say that listening to his English I would never say that he has any Polish accent. To me his English sounds as a pure, well educated English, not any colloquialism, not an American English, not an English from upper classes in England.
Just pure, easy understood English, I would say, without any special accent.
Such being the case I would suspect that his accent is pure and good in any language he is teaching. Just think what an accent is. It is trying to speak with sounds and intonation exactly the same as speak the people in a specified area in a specific country. This is an utopia.
It does not make any sense to try to do that by a foreign. Firstly, because it is impossible unless you are born there, secondly, because there is multiple accents spoken in every country. For example, in Poland I am easily recognized that I was not born in Krakow or Katowice if I go there because I was born near Poznan.
I agree however, that using only Michel Thomas method I have difficulties to learn Spanish and not to memorizing things is more a marketing trick than reality. If one wants to learn anything he or she must make an effort to memorize it.
===========================================
Ed - As a native English speaker I would say that Mr Thomas has a heavy foreign accent, and I would certainly not call it 'pure'. I guess it depends on what one defines as pure and educated.
Really?
The issue with his accent is completely overblown.
Any idiot can hear his accent and differentiate it from the core teaching.
After I did the Spanish course, which was amazing, my accent was consistently complimented. zxz simply because I was able to hear what he was trying to teach.
All these reviews assume the listener is stupid beyond belief. I'd like to see how many French speakers are out there with Polish accents as a result of Thomas - my guess is not many.
Review on Michel Thomas Spanish Course
Hi, I'm a native spanish speaker and from my point of view Michel Thomas Spanish course is excellent;All I can say it's just excellent;Very recomended.
I was searching some reviews on Michel Thomas German Course and ended up in this website, so I downloaded the fist three lessons of Michel Thomas Spanish course, and was so funny to listen him speaking spanish (he does speaks spanish like a native speaker).
So,now with reviews I founded in this website and from my own experience with Mr Thomas Spanish course,I have no doubt I'm learning from the best teacher.
Again,VERY RECOMMENDED!
Michel Thomas French
I spent many years trying to learn French,started in school, then several years at evening classes. kept trying but to no avail, because everyone taught with written work and lots of grammar to learn I just couldn't get it.
What Michel said made complete sense -
children learn to talk a long while before learning to read, and those who are unable to read can still talk.
As soon as I started with these discs I began to speak French starting with talking to myself whilst driving etc. Late in life, when I was about 63 I moved to Brittany for 5 years and could hold my own in conversations with neighbors and friends (French born).
I am now 70 and a about to start learning German, again with Michel Thomas.
Great but... (Dutch)
I've been using the Dutch cd and I have to say, I am extremely happy with the way the content is structured and presented by the teachers (two native speaker ladies), and I have picked the basics up really quickly.
I think it is a very good, effective and motivating start if you want to study a language by yourself, and makes the use of any further materials, grammar books, vocab etc. a lot easier to process than without these basics.
Cons:
The two students. Why do I need to listen to some people constantly make mistakes? If it was just the occasional error, but there is one word repeated quite a few dozen times (doen = to do) that both students pronounce incorrectly every single time, up to the end of the advanced course! Why couldn't they just stop the recording, and continued once they got it right? I actually started pronouncing it like that myself, how could I not have?
Since then I have spent many precious hours trying to edit out the students. Would it not have been better for everybody if they had just recorded it without them?
Out of curiousity, I listened to the Spanish one a little, and I can safely say, I would not be able to listen to that course for more than an hour. It's not just his accent, I just cannot stand his voice.
Also, the Advanced course is of course clearly not advanced. The title should be more accurate in case anyone thinks they can become advanced speakers in 15 hours.
If they re-recorded his own cds with a new teacher (and without the students!), I would be more likely to buy them.
(By the way, if somebody has already cut the students out from the advanced course, please let me know, I've still got that to do.)
Michel Thomas French and German courses
I have the three German courses, have completed them all as well as the French course-but not the Language Builder or Advanced French courses which I would like to obtain.
As for the German courses they are excellent but I must add that I have a Basic Berlitz German course as well as LinguAPHONE.
I AM ALSO USING A LINGUAPHONE fRENCH COURSE BUT like the German it is quite old and in addition I have studied German with the Open University and am nearing the completion of their Beginners' French.
Michel Thomas has been a great help in mastering basic phrases and structures and I can recommend the courses for this, but I think I need the two later courses in French before I can say I have a real grasp of the language
Challenge on Memorization
I've just started learning Portuguese using the Michel Thomas method. There is a British teacher (I think the course was made after Michel died) but there is a native European Portuguese speaker who enunciates all the words and sentences.
Your point about the "no memorization" being part of a sales pitch I think is a little pedantic and I don't think it accurately reflects what the method really expects of you.
You are stating the obvious when you say that, for something to sink in, it has to be remembered.
I doubt Michel would have argued with you. What the course asks is that you do not make a mental effort to remember by revision and that you do not overly try to make a point of remembering.
That the importance of actually remembering what you've learned was recognised by Michel could be seen in his introductory statements: "Never TRY to remember...because...the RESPONSIBILITY OF REMEMBERING lies with the teaching and not with you; not with the learner"
To borrow your illustration: He's not calling an elephant a donkey; he's calling an it an elephant, but he's saying he's the rider, you're the passenger.
So with the greatest respect, those reading your review should ignore that part of it, as you are introducing stress into the process, which is exactly what the method tries to eliminate.
Michel Thomas Portuguese
I can thoroughly recommend the Portuguese course. Having listened to Michel teach Spanish (and I do speak Spanish already), I was disappointed on two counts; one, was his atrocious accent, and two, he taught South American Spanish, not Castellano.
The Portuguese course, however, is completely different. It is presented by Virginia Catmur, an English lady who speaks excellent Portuguese, and who explains the lessons with great humour and patience, encouraging two students to figure out for themselves the construction she is aiming for, and then invites a native Portuguese gentleman to speak the word/phrase/sentence in an authentic Lisbon accent.
The two students, by the way, are a male and a female, have very different language abilities. You may well become exasperated with one of them (I shan't tell you which one - it will become obvious after about disc 2!).
I have the full set of CDs - from the foundation to the advanced, 12 discs in all - and it does take you from knowing nothing to being able to converse with portuguese people in their own language, albeit slowly.
I do have a caveat, though, and that is the advanced course is still what I would consider "colloquial" level, and you do really need to augment the course with another read & write course to get a broader understanding.
From my point of view, already speaking Spanish is both an advantage and a disadvantage. The advantage is the obvious similarity in the two languages, with a huge common pool of words.
The disadvantage is, Portuguese accent and inflection is completely different, and can catch you out at every turn. It may be easy to read Portuguese as a Spanish speaker, but the Michel Thomas course has been invaluable to me for getting my accent and inflection more on track, and steering me away from merely trying to speak Spanish in a Portuguese accent!
Everything everyone has said is correct, BUT ...
I think the way he breaks down the language it makes it much easier to learn the essentials and start to think in the language. All those other things lists can happen later.
This has been especially true of the chinese course (completed post humously). Learning chinese is like learning telephone numbers. Anything which makes it easier is a blessing. Only the Michel Thomas course came anywhere near helping. (They did have a native chinese speaker.)
I like Michel
I've used several of Michel Thomas's courses and found them useful. I think the review above misses out why they're good: they provide an excellent TEMPLATE for language learning.
Uniquely, Michel builds language from the basic "I want", adding structures and words bit by bit to that so that the student starts to understand how the language is constructed.
Most other language systems are poorly structured in this respect and don't build, so as you progress you end up being allowed to forget words and concepts you learned early on.
I feel to learn a language properly, you have to use various methods, and Michel Thomas can be a very useful first one. It's not fair to criticise him for not providing a fully comprehensive language system - no where does he suggest it's anything more than an audio version of the teaching method he uses with his paid students - but he's definitely on to something.
Without using a book or worksheet, just listening to the tuition, you learn quite a few words and concepts in a short space of time in a friendly, encouraging way. Sometimes Michel gets sidetracked and that can be amusing - for instance in the Spanish course where explaining the word "sera" he mentions the song "Que Sera Sera - adding that he taught Doris Day.
I feel also that his own thick polyglot accent can be a bit of a confidence booster to the student struggling with pronunciation - you feel you can often do better than him. He certainly makes the whole business of language learning seem attainable.
Chinese Mandarin
I have just finished the Foundation Course in Mandarin,this I found very interesting.
It was at the right pace and there was a young lady from Beijing to give the correct accent.
However on going on to the Advanced Cds things changed, it states that these CDs follow on from the Foundation CDs,but I am finding it almost impossible to connect the two courses.Luckily I borrowed the CDs from the local library so nothing is lost.
Michel Thomas' accent
I have done the beginning and advanced French and Portuguese courses, intend to get the German and Japanese Advanced. I have a good ear for accents and dialects, and have known a few Poles. I would agree that MT's accent in English shows he is obviously not a native English speaker, however, it is a gross exaggeration to say that he has a thick Polish accent.
Like when I am speaking Japanese, my Japanese friends tell me my although accent is very good, and they can tell I am not native Japanese, they also can not easily tell from which country I come.
Likewise, Michel Thomas' accent in French could possibly be pinned down to a few non latin countries, but it would take a superb musician with a lot of linguistic experience to tell he is Polish.
His accent in French is pretty good, much better than most adult learners of French would ever achieve. I think your criticisms are a carping rant, and I put Michel Thomas' courses as a desirable, even almost essential, though not sole, tool in the learning of a new language.
I would now feel somewhat handicapped in learning a language if a Michel Thomas course were not available.
Michel's French
I am French and I listened to a few of MT's French courses out of curiosity and found his accent quite all right.
I think the MT method is a great shortcut to learn foreign languages. So many people lose interest after the first weeks or months of learning a new language because of all the work it takes, because of the tediousness of learning lists of irregular verbs or filling in blanks in boring exercises.
The MT method gives you vocabulary, a sense of a language's grammar and confidence. And you get this with a 12-hour course, i.e. within 12 days or less.
After that, you can start learning that language in a book (and you'll find it much easier than if you started without the MT method) but you'll also be able to engage in small conversations, watch simple movies... and this could boost your motivation, which is, after all what is needed to learn a language.
I have no connection to the MT company, I'm not trying to advertise his products here. I'm just a user, who also happens to have taught French in the past, and I find this method amazing.
I've learnt Dutch and Italian with the MT method and it worked wonders for me. It helps you assimilate complex grammatical rules in an intuitive way.
Of course you're going to need to keep learning the language in question once you're done with the MT method, and you're going to want to really work on the written language, but hey, isn't this how kids learn to speak? They first learn the language, and only after five or six years they start learning to read & write :-)
Native Speakers
There is a native speaker for the Japanese courses which is very helpful. I did learn hiragana and katakana and created my own written lessons based on the sentences given in the lessons. This proved to be very helpful.
Cross purposes
The author of this article is correct when he says you need to learn from a variety of sources. But the Michel Thomas method is about learning the basics rapidly and thus giving the student confidence. The fact that Michel Thomas has a Polish accent is less important .
Michel Thomas for the first time learner
I have tried many times to learn French over the years and always become bored with the courses - both class courses and home study - NOT so with Michel Thomas - I cannot put it down and am progressing at a rate of knots that I would never have dreamed possible. Truly, in one hour I learnt, and just as importantly, digested and retained all that the Course gave me - its that good.
As Michel says "There is no such thing as a bad student - just a bad teacher" Aint that the truth!
I remember my maths lessons at school I was hopeless and came bottom of the class every year and It was purely down to bad teaching methods. I took matters into my own hands after leaving school and found a good tutor who taught differently and ended up passing every exam with honours - I now teach maths.
I do not know why this material by Michel Thomas sticks in your memory banks but it does.Perhaps its because he was a successful psychology professor and he understands the workings of the mind - whatever it is - it works!
As regards accent. I cant judge whether he`s good or bad just yet. I find that the accent comes "from within" I can "do" a good French accent - it is easy for me to do; however I would say to anyone wishing to learn French just concentrate on learning the language first then work on the accent later.
Someone who learnt french using michel tomas's CDs
I think that if you already know the language, then you will not be impressed by the CDs, but if you are new to the language (especially if you tried and failed to learn a foreign language before) you will be impressed at what you have learnt in a short time.
However I did get stuck after CD 4. I think I needed a personal tutor. I have recently discovered the review CD that may allow me to patch over the holes and continue.
A note on memory: Michel does not state that you will not remember; He states that you should not try to remember. This may seem a little strange but it simply states that your trying is wrong. You do not know how to remember. Let go of all responsibility of remembering. Just relax and do what you are told. I will be responsibly. You will remember.
On audio: I have never been able to use self study books as I have no idea how to pronounce the words.
I Live in France and...
Hi,
My Wife and I have lived in France for a good portion of each year (around half) for the last 10 years. Prior to that, I had studied a year of French way back in college and my wife and done an immersion course many years before. I also tried a basic course with the Alliance Française. All felt useful while doing it, but none of it really stuck. In practical terms, we came here speaking no French.
We tried working with a private teacher, which helped to some extent. But she got stuck on a very repetitive teaching schedule of endlessly reading Jules Verne stories aloud. So we quit that too.
But then a friend gave us the Michel Thomas CDs and that changed everything. I don't know how useful it is at the advanced level, but the foundation level was excellent. It gave us the real common works of conversation (instead of just tourist phrases) and a phrase structure that was easy to remember and adapt to new situations.
I think that was, above all, the big difference. Other language courses teach you words and phrases for a specific context. Thomas' courses give you tools you can use universally while trying out the language.
We were soon lucky enough to make friends with a large group of French speakers (via one bilingual contact between us and the group), and the Michel Thomas lessons gave us a base upon which to build the relationship.
We've recommended it highly to many friends since then.
Who remembers the critic?
As a native English speaker, the opportunities to speak another language are greatly diminished as every foreign person I meet is trying to learn English!
The point of language is communication and that means primarily through speach. When we begin learning as toddlers we don't start reading and writing do we?
The Michel Thomas method is an excellent way to help you overcome the barriers to start speaking, which coincidently I am told by many students of foreign languages is so hard to do.
==================================
Ed - if you want to hear how a language should really sound, always get some audio material that has native speakers. Or get a some practice with a teacher or speakers that are native speakers. If you happy with some other accent ... go for it. It's a free world.
Interesting if misguided review
The memorisation point you make shows a lack of attention to what is being said. He is specifically taking the responsibility for you building the memories.
As such you are not actively required to memorise, but through a process of gradual exposure, active participation, and timed recapitulations, memories are formed at a procedural level.
As such, the student is never required to actively pursue exercises in memorisation. His approach reflects an understanding of the methods most suited to retention, and reflects best practice given current understanding of memory.
It would be useful for those interested to read the book on his teaching method, which rather enlightening and ties his method into the current understanding.
For my part as an educationalist, I have found his technique very effective.
I have learned french, something no amount of traditional approaches achieved. I go frequently to France and engage fully in all sorts of circumstances, from social to commercial. for this I am most grateful to Michel's method.
Kindest regards
Seán
PS. Michel Thomas's accent is when compared to the more Germanic parts of France and Switzerland is not at all odd. I have never had a problem being understood on pronunciation grounds.
--------------------
Michel Thomas's website on the page entitled 'The Michel Thomas Method: How it Works' states quite clearly in plain English.
"No books. No writing. No memorising. Just confidence – fast."
"There is no need to stop for homework, additional exercises or vocabulary memorisation."
Spanish with Michel Thomas
I used the Spanish language CD's basic and advanced before traveling to Salamanca in Castile Leon Spain. Not only was congratulated on my understanding of Spanish I also received very favourable comment on my accent and pronunciation.
This coming from native Spanish speakers in what is known as the Cambridge of Spain i.e. Salamanca is where the purest Spanish is taught and spoken you find very few locals who speak anything other than Spanish and French.
I picked up a copy of El Pais and have read it regularly ever since.
Once you have undertaken any language course the real secret is using what you have learned in order to listen to and read and write the language at every opportunity.
Funnily enough that is what we do as children - we learn the audio from our parents then we learn to read and write - seems normal enough to me.
Oh my daughter was born in England but since we moved to Scotland when she was 3 she speaks with a very strong East of Scotland Accent - No hay problema
Steve
So what!! Accent who cares, Speak- that's what counts!!
Michel Thomas method is a great intro to learning a language and that is what it is meant to be.
I have the course as an iPhone app which is great value for money.
It is inspiring enough for the learner to want to read and take what they have learn further.
I agree that you do some memorising but what you learn is easily imbedded in your brain and I even fine myself thinking in the language, so it works very well, even addictive once you get started.
Does it really matter what accent, if I a foreigner speaks English?
I have little idea of where they're from and I think that will be the same for a French person is they hear a non-native.
Better to speak with a Polish accent than not even trying to speak French.
Italian and French courses
I've been listening to the French course, and yes, his accent is noticeable and the fact you'll struggle to read and write anything clearly suggests that this method is to teach you speak only. That's exactly what I wanted, as I speak pretty good Italian and felt going through a book and CD format would bore me as I could guess the answers.
I looked up the Italian course out of interest on youtube, and his Italian, while excellent, is heavily accented. My Italian is good enough to spot a few different accents and his is clearly northern European - I used to work with a Dutch woman who sounded just like that in Italian.
All of which is a long-winded way of saying what a useful site this is, and to pass on my tip for trying to improve your accent in a foreign language.
Start out by saying something in English with, say, a French accent, then move into saying French in that way. It's not foolproof but will make you sound a little bit better - there's a reason the French and Italians sound the way they do in English!
-------------------------------------
Good tip Danny. Thanks... and don't forget to wave your hands and contort your face in a 'French' or 'Italian' way! -Editor
Michiel Thomas Spanish Courses are Excellent Tools for the Spanish Student
My experience with Michel Thomas Spanish cources has been excellent. His teaching techniques are excellent for learning while you are driving.
Also, I do not get tired of listening as I do on many other boring CD courses. I travel a lot and it is very difficult for me to attend reguarly scheduled classes (which I have done in the past).
I agree with the comments above that you cannot
learn Spanish without writing, etc.; however, Thomas's courses are an absolutely excellent "tool" to supplement other methods and courses. I have listened to his beginning and advanced CD's several times and always pick up on things that I did not learn in any other course. I am sad that he is not still around as I would definately buy any new courses he would produce. For Spanish, I do not have any major issues with his acent.
Also, I believe that other CD courses should use the student - teacher interaction approach as has Michel Thomas, as it is a bit like being in a class and learning from others.
For me, he is a very much appreciated part of my Spanish learning experience, as I have learned a lot from him.
Thanks very much for all, Michel!!
His Spanish accent is dreadful.
I'm Polish myself, and after 4 years of intensively learning Spanish I can safely say my accent is much better than his. Even though it's a language similar to italian, he doesn't do a very good job of pronouncing it, sorry to say.
I don't mean to criticize the method itself, as atm I'm using his audio to learn french (and I really appreciate having read your review, btw!) and I do find it very useful. However if that's what his Spanish accent is, I'm starting to worry about the French one.. (which obviously I can't judge yet!)
Regarding Michel Thomas' Accent.
You advised against Michel Thomas' accent in his French Program. The accent is a none issue as long as one understands what is being said. Even people who live within the same country and do speak the same language, depending on which region of that country they are from, will have an accent.
Case in point, I reside within the United States, and a person from the State of Texas will speak differently from someone from the State of New York. Michel Thomas' program is a great place to start if you want start speaking another language immediately.
The only complaint I do have about the program is that it does not offer enough languages. I have used the program for Spanish, French, Italian, Portuuese, and Mandarin for starters and the FSI language program offered by the U.S. Department of State.
The best thing about Michel Thomas' program is that the language being thought is broken down into parts which enables you to reassemble those parts to formulate your own ideas in your newly acquired language.
Michel Thomas Course is great
I have studied many courses. Thomas's is great for any beginner. Living language is also good and inexpensive, buy the course under 20. You can buy virtually everything offered for a language by Thomas for under 200 but first 8 disk can be bought for under 50. Goes great with Rosetta stone which is overpriced but good. Buy a dictionary with rosetta. Thomas is great for anyone who drives a lot.
Michel's accent
I just wanted to say that Michel's accent was nowhere near Polish. I can tell that because I'm Polish. His accent is a mix between american-english and german, but when it came to speaking in french his pronouncation was quite excellent (I can say that because I live in France). So, if you pronounce the words and sentences like Michel does, you will not have a German accent nor a Polish one.
-----------------------------------------------
Editor comments: Nor a French one. Michel Thomas does not have an American-English accent. I'd suggest you ask a native French speaker to rate his accent, rather than a Pole living in France.
Mickey T's accent
I agree with the comment that Michel Thomas' French and Spanish accents leave a lot to be desired.
As for this requiring a "Severe Language Health Warning", I feel more than a little exaggeration has been employed here.
The methodology is perfectly sound for learning the basics of a language that are used right up to the highest levels. Indeed, I have not come across any other method that teaches the foundations or the building blocks of a language so quickly, and, as both a language teacher and a language learner, I have wide experience many courses.
There is a plethora of French and Spanish audio recordings on the Net at all levels (the BBC website being particularly useful) and it should not be difficult to listen to a native speaker and copy the correct pronunciation within one's own personal limits.
Once the learner has finished the course(s) he or she can then carry on at a more advanced level which will include reading and writing.
Having said this, Mr T would have been better off letting a native speaker talk the talk, as is the case with the Russian, Polish and Japanese courses and most of the others as far as I know.
As for the claims that no memorisation is required, I believe this is no more than good old fashioned advertising hyperbole, after all no one was really naive enough to believe that Heineken reached the parts that other beers did not, or were they?
Michel Thomas`s Accent
Hi, I'm English learning Spanish, and while I'm unable to talk about Michel Thomas`s Spanish accent, I can speak about his English accent, which is very good although I thought he were a Dutch guy teaching Englishmen how to speak Spanish.
Does the accent really matter?
I mean when he`s teaching French Germans and others how to speak English Im sure he`s more than competent to do this, more so than a native Englishman from Liverpool or Newcastle who have real strong regional accents that the majority of native English have trouble understanding.
If this was the case then anyone from the two cities mentioned above who spoke a fluent language and decided to teach English, according to you they would be speaking English with a Scouse or Geordie accent, "or would they ?" would they not be speaking English with a Scouse or Geordie french accent lol, I think not as long as the words are correct they will naturally speak English with there native accents.
I doubt when I go to Spain any native Spaniard would think Im from Poland.
Regarding your Michel Thomas Review
I think you've focused rather heavily on the fact that he has a foreign accent when speaking English and French, and perhaps not enough on how effective the language courses actually are.
'I cannot comment on the accent on the Michel Thomas Spanish course, Michel Thomas Italian, Michel Thomas Portuguese, Michel Thomas German course or the Michael Thomas anything else.'
I agree with Susan about his Italian accent not being far off, however, not being a native speaker, I can't give a very accurate opinion of it. The same goes for his Spanish accent.
I can tell you, however, that his German accent is native. He has no trace of a foreign accent, and speaks German as his second mother tongue.
He has never done a Portuguese course, only French, German, Italian and Spanish. There is a Portuguese (and Chinese, and Russian) course that uses his method, but it wasn't made by him.
I recommend that everyone read his biography - it's fascinating, and really gives an insight into live during the Second World War.
How your mind works and Michel Thomas
I haven't tried Michel Thomas's course. I'm conscious that my learning and therefore how my mind is structured is very classical. I'm Italian and I studied Latin and ancient Greek. I need a text in front of me and grammatical rules.
What sore puss comments
This was obviously written by a teacher who thinks they are the only people who can teach. We have lived in Chile for 15 years and despite working quite hard at it, and we speak Spanish all the time, we never have mastered the basic structure. That means we can communicate on a day to day basis but not in a really intellectual nor educated way.
Working through Michel Thomas's lessons is like breath of fresh air. He is one, of only a very limited number of teachers, who have the intelligence and ability to break something down into its components in a form that goes into the brain and stimulate the student 100 % at the same time.
Now that we are getting to grips in real way with Spanish we are starting on his french course prior to a months cycle holiday through France
It's sad when one teacher cannot realise how brilliant another teacher is and how much pleasure to the process of learning they give.
Ian
He ain't all that bad!
I think that one of the advantages of the M. Thomas approach is that he triggers the learner into speaking in a way that other courses ( that I have used at least ) do not.
He provides simple psychological boosters to give confidence to the speaker. This actually I think is a key barrier in the failure of many to learn to speak foreign languages in England.
I learnt and passed academic GCE French at 16 years of age, forty five years ago! ( this included an oral exam).
But it was only when I used the M Thomas course I actually have the cofidence to converse in French, when in France. The course actually taught me little or no French that I hadn't done before.. but by concentrating on modal verbs etc.. and giving these psychological triggers, I was enabled to make the jump from reading and writing French ( which was what the oldfashioned GCE did), to actually speaking.
I think he is pretty good! However I agree that the range of material is too limited to go beyond a certain set of language situations , and a mix of learning materials , including old fashioned text books, multi-media and "memorisation" materials is necessary.
Ed Ball
Love Michel Thomas
I've always wanted to study French, but with working forty hours a week found I couldn't devote enough time to the language. With his course I've been able to learn French much faster and in an enjoyable way.
His ability to break it down into such simple structures has given me a huge boost in confidence. So much so, that when we had visitors from France stay with us, I was able to converse with them. More importantly, they understood what I was saying! That in my book makes it successful.
References
- Michel Thomas Method (Hodder & Stoughton). https://www.michelthomas.com/
- U.S. Department of State, Foreign Service Institute. Foreign Language Training (language difficulty categories and hours). https://www.state.gov/foreign-language-training/
Kevin Crocombe
Creator of 200 Words a Day
Kevin created 200 Words a Day and wrote the original site's articles on memory, verbs and language learning. He learnt French as an 11-year-old at a boarding school in New Caledonia, where nobody spoke English.
Try 200 Words a Day
Learn vocab that actually sticks
200 Words a Day hooks every word onto a cartoon, making it hard to forget. 10 free lessons in every vocab course, no credit card needed.
