Course review
Language learning reviews: how to read them
Why so many language course reviews online can't be trusted
5 min readLast updated: October 2026
Beware of language learning reviews on the web. Many are written by affiliate marketers who earn a commission if you buy from the website they link you to.
So many reviews tell you little about whether a course is any good.
When a site ranks a list of language courses, the one ranked highest may simply be the one that pays the most commission.
When reading any product review of any language learning product you must consider the motivation of the writer, and the publication or the media vehicle.
The trouble is that many online reviews are written by affiliates of the products they review.
What it means is that you really have to do the research yourself or check out some forums for the views of other learners.
What is an affiliate, or an associate?
It is a company that is acting as agent for another company selling a product. One of the world's biggest affiliate companies is amazon.com, and they did more than anyone to popularise affiliate (or associate) marketing. Anyone with a website can become an affiliate of amazon.com for free.
Since this was written, fake reviews and undisclosed paid reviews have become illegal in the United States (2024) and the United Kingdom (2025), so a reviewer who earns a commission now has to say so. Look for the disclosure.
How does the affiliate get paid? The affiliate or associate writes a webpage and puts this on his/her website. The webpage is written on a product that amazon.com sells, for example a language course.
When a websurfer finds the page and reads the blurb the affiliate is hoping that the websurfer clicks one of the (usually several) links from the webpage and will be taken to the amazon.com website.
Embedded in that link from the affiliate website to the amazon.com website is a little piece of code with the affiliate's account number and this tells amazon exactly which affiliate sent the surfer. The code registers in the amazon database, and if the surfer buys a product, the affiliate then gets a commission.
You can often actually see the affiliate link in the coding at the bottom of your internet browser when you hover your mouse over the link text.
This affiliate marketing or associate marketing is a multibillion dollar industry now in terms of sales and companies like amazon have tens of thousands of affiliates and associates.
There are literally thousands of companies that have affiliate schemes where webmasters sell the wares of the merchant through these little links
So a review full of gushing praise may be designed mainly to get you to click through and buy, and its writer may never have used the product.
The lesson: do your own research
The lesson from all this is that if you are looking for language learning reviews of substance, of actual credibility you need to do a fair amount of your own research to come up with the right answers.
The next problem is that very few people have the time to really review all the courses (good and not so good) out there in the marketplace. So the really skilled language teachers that are out there and that are qualified to compare one course with another really do not get to view more than a small handful of courses!
Check out my reviews of various language learning products, and do remember that I make and sell my own language courses (200 Words a Day, now a web app), so my reviews will reflect my own biases. I don't use affiliate links.
- Michel Thomas
- Pimsleur
- Linkword
- The Third Ear
- Earworms
- French in Action
- The FSI courses
- French Bescherelle and Spanish Bescherelle
- The Memory Masters
- Moonwalking with Einstein
- Champs-Elysées audio magazines
However, I can tell you that as a person who enjoys learning words, expressions and phrases in different languages, and who is constantly assessing various language learning products for ideas and methodology I can always provide you some insights of value.
Some pointers
Overall I can make some comments for you to take away about the language learning products out there.
- Never before has there been so much good product for language learners available.
- Many of the top brands are of good quality.
- To learn a language properly requires a huge amount of dedicated input - about 600 to 750 class hours for French or Spanish, 900 for German, and around 2,200 for Arabic, Chinese, Japanese or Korean, to become professionally competent according to the US Foreign Service Institute.
- You can pick up words and phrases quickly, and these are all that are needed to get started and to have the locals appreciate you making an effort.
- In my experience, getting to a basic level of conversation needs about 60-100 hours of study.
- You will advance by having regular conversations with a good teacher - and this should be at least two hours per week. To be serious about learning a language you should allow 6 to 10 hours a week.
- At some stage you should consolidate with a period of language immersion.
- You can create your own immersion situation.
- Many language learners never get beyond the ability to carry out more than a very small conversation in the foreign language they learn, despite sometimes years of study.
A key lesson to learn from this is that the student that wants to learn can use one, or more, of many available techniques and courses, and will succeed with quite a high degree of hard work.
If you are going to achieve fluency you will need to put in several hundred hours of study, and should spend at least 6 to 12 months in a total immersion situation.
Using accelerated techniques will greatly improve this process, but still many hundreds of hours of study are needed to get a solid grounding in a language, and putting the material that you learn in to conversation.
References
- U.S. Department of State, Foreign Service Institute. Foreign Language Training (language difficulty categories and hours). https://www.state.gov/foreign-language-training/
- Federal Trade Commission (2024). Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465. https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/rules/consumer-reviews-testimonials
- Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (UK). https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2024/13
Kevin Crocombe
Creator of 200 Words a Day
Kevin created 200 Words a Day and wrote the original site's articles on memory, verbs and language learning. He learnt French as an 11-year-old at a boarding school in New Caledonia, where nobody spoke English.
Try 200 Words a Day
Learn words in minutes, not weeks
Visual memory triggers make new words stick as quickly as day one. Start free today, no credit card needed.
